Posts
The Brutal Truth About Why Your Team Keeps Stuffing Up Customer Calls (And It's Not What You Think)
Related Reading:
Here's something that'll make you uncomfortable: your customer service training is probably making things worse.
I know, I know. You've invested thousands in those glossy programs. You've sat through presentations about "active listening" and "empathy mapping." Your team has role-played difficult scenarios until they could recite the scripts in their sleep. Yet somehow, customers are still hanging up frustrated, your team's morale is in the toilet, and you're scratching your head wondering where it all went wrong.
After 17 years of fixing broken customer service departments across Melbourne, Sydney, and Brisbane, I've seen this pattern more times than I care to count. The problem isn't that your people don't care – it's that we've been teaching them to perform empathy instead of actually feeling it.
The Performance Trap That's Killing Your Results
Let me paint you a picture. Sarah from your call centre answers the phone. Customer's furious about a billing error. Sarah takes a breath, lowers her voice to that trained "concerned" tone, and says, "I understand how frustrating this must be for you, Mr Johnson."
But here's the thing – Sarah doesn't understand. She's never been charged incorrectly for something she didn't buy. She's following a script, not connecting with a human being. Mr Johnson picks up on this immediately because humans are bloody brilliant at detecting authenticity. Even through a phone line.
The result? Mr Johnson gets more frustrated because he feels like he's talking to a robot. Sarah gets defensive because she's doing exactly what she was trained to do. The call escalates. Everyone loses.
Sound familiar?
Why Traditional Training Creates Empathy Theatre
Most customer service training focuses on what I call "empathy theatre" – the performance of caring rather than the genuine article. We teach people to say the right words, use the right tone, follow the right process. But we never teach them to actually connect with the person on the other end of the line.
I learned this the hard way when I was running customer service for a telecommunications company back in 2009. We had the highest "customer satisfaction" scores in the industry according to our surveys, but our churn rate was through the roof. Customers were saying they were satisfied, then leaving us for competitors.
Turns out, people were rating the politeness of our staff, not the resolution of their problems. We were getting gold stars for being nice while completely failing to address what customers actually needed.
That's when I realised we'd been asking the wrong question entirely.
The Real Question Nobody's Teaching Your Team
Instead of "How can I sound more empathetic?" your team should be asking "What does this person actually need right now?"
Sometimes what they need is an apology. Sometimes it's a refund. Sometimes it's just to be heard by another human being who acknowledges that yes, this situation is genuinely annoying and they have every right to be frustrated.
But here's what they never need: a scripted response that makes them feel like they're talking to a chatbot with better pronunciation.
I remember working with a small business in Perth – won't name them, but they sold outdoor equipment. Their biggest complaint was about delivery delays. The owner had trained his team to offer a 10% discount whenever someone called about late deliveries. Seemed reasonable, right?
Wrong. What customers actually wanted was just to know when their gear would arrive so they could plan their weekend camping trip. The discount was nice, but it didn't solve their real problem.
Once we shifted the focus from "make them happy" to "solve their actual problem," complaints dropped by 60% in three months. Same team, same products, completely different approach.
The Three Things That Actually Matter (And They're Not What You Think)
After analysing hundreds of customer interactions across different industries, I've identified three factors that consistently predict whether a customer call will go well:
1. Genuine Curiosity About the Customer's Situation
Your team needs to actually want to understand what's happening in the customer's world. Not so they can categorise the complaint or find the right response template, but because they're genuinely interested in helping another person.
This isn't something you can script. It's an attitude shift that starts with hiring people who naturally care about others, then giving them the tools and authority to actually help.
2. Permission to Deviate from the Process
Here's a radical idea: sometimes the process is wrong. Sometimes the customer's situation is unique enough that following standard procedure will make things worse, not better.
Your best team members need permission to use their judgment. Yes, this means sometimes they'll make mistakes. But the cost of those occasional errors is nothing compared to the damage caused by rigid adherence to processes that don't fit every situation.
3. Understanding the Emotional Journey, Not Just the Transaction
Every customer who calls you is in the middle of a story. Maybe they're trying to organise something special for their partner's birthday. Maybe they're dealing with a family crisis and this problem is just one more thing on a very long list.
Your team doesn't need to become therapists, but they do need to recognise that they're dealing with whole human beings, not just transaction numbers.
Why Most Companies Get This So Wrong
The biggest mistake I see companies make is treating customer service like a cost centre instead of a revenue driver. When you're focused purely on efficiency metrics – call times, resolution rates, customer satisfaction scores – you optimise for the wrong outcomes.
You end up with teams that are brilliant at processing complaints quickly but terrible at actually solving problems. You get high satisfaction scores from customers who are too polite to give negative feedback, while the ones who really matter – your advocates and repeat buyers – slip away quietly.
I've seen this play out differently across various industries. Retail businesses often get caught up in return policies that prioritise protecting inventory over keeping customers. Financial services companies become so risk-averse that they can't make common-sense exceptions for genuine hardship cases.
But the companies that get it right? They understand that every customer interaction is an opportunity to strengthen or weaken the relationship. They measure success not just by how quickly problems get resolved, but by how customers feel about the company afterward.
The Uncomfortable Truth About Customer Emotions
Here's something that might surprise you: angry customers aren't your biggest problem. Disappointed customers are.
Angry customers still care enough to fight for a solution. They'll give you multiple chances to make things right because they want to maintain the relationship. Disappointed customers have already given up. They're polite, they say "no worries" when you can't help them, and then they never buy from you again.
Your team needs to learn to recognise disappointment, not just anger. It's subtle, but it's often more damaging to your business in the long run.
Most training focuses on de-escalation techniques for angry customers – which is useful – but completely ignores the quiet disappointment that loses you customers forever.
What Actually Works (Based on Real Results, Not Theory)
Let me tell you about a manufacturing company in Adelaide I worked with last year. They were losing major clients because of communication breakdowns when orders went wrong. Nothing catastrophic – just regular stuff-ups that happen in any business.
The problem wasn't the mistakes themselves. It was how they handled them.
Their customer service team had been trained to focus on resolution speed. Get the problem fixed, move on to the next call. Efficient, professional, forgettable.
We completely flipped their approach. Instead of rushing to fix things, we taught them to slow down and really understand the impact of each problem on the customer's business.
Suddenly, instead of just replacing faulty parts, they were helping customers adjust their production schedules. Instead of offering standard discounts, they were finding creative ways to prevent similar problems in the future.
Customer retention went from 73% to 94% in eight months.
The key wasn't better training materials or more sophisticated processes. It was shifting from transaction-focused thinking to relationship-focused thinking.
The Questions Your Team Should Actually Be Asking
Forget "How may I help you today?" – everyone uses that. Here are the questions that actually make a difference:
"What were you hoping would happen?" "How is this affecting your day/business/plans?" "What would a good outcome look like from your perspective?"
These questions do two things: they show genuine interest in the customer's situation, and they give your team information they can actually use to provide better solutions.
But here's the crucial part – your team needs to actually listen to the answers. Not just wait for their turn to speak, but genuinely absorb what the customer is telling them.
The Authority Problem Nobody Talks About
One of the biggest frustrations customers have is being transferred between multiple people, each with limited authority to actually solve problems. You know the drill – "I'll need to check with my supervisor" becomes the death knell of customer satisfaction.
Here's what I tell every business owner: give your front-line team more authority to make decisions. Yes, some will make expensive choices. But the cost of those decisions is usually far less than the cost of losing customers who get fed up with bureaucracy.
A local furniture retailer I worked with gave their customer service team authority to approve refunds up to $500 without manager approval. Did some customers take advantage? Probably. But their customer satisfaction scores jumped 23 points, and more importantly, their word-of-mouth referrals increased dramatically.
The math is simple: the cost of occasionally getting ripped off is nothing compared to the cost of systematically frustrating legitimate customers.
Technology Isn't the Enemy (But It's Not the Solution Either)
I get asked about AI and chatbots constantly. "Should we automate our customer service?" The answer is nuanced.
Technology is brilliant for handling routine inquiries – order status, basic account information, frequently asked questions. But the moment a customer has a problem that doesn't fit a standard category, you need human judgment and creativity.
The best approach I've seen combines both: use technology to handle the simple stuff efficiently, then route anything complex to humans who actually have the tools and authority to solve problems.
But please, for the love of all that's holy, don't make customers fight through seventeen menu options to speak to a person. Nothing starts a conversation off on the wrong foot quite like spending ten minutes trying to reach a human being.
The Training That Actually Works
Real customer service training should feel more like coaching than classroom instruction. Your team needs to practice real scenarios with real stakes, not role-play exercises where everyone knows the "right" answer.
Here's what I recommend:
Record real customer calls (with permission) and analyse them together. Not to criticise individual performance, but to identify patterns and learn from both successes and failures.
Shadow your best performers and figure out what they do differently. Often, your top people can't articulate why they're successful – they just have good instincts. Make those instincts learnable.
Practice saying no gracefully. Sometimes you genuinely can't help a customer, but how you deliver that message makes all the difference between someone who understands your limitations and someone who feels dismissed.
The goal isn't to turn everyone into identical customer service robots. It's to give each person the skills and confidence to handle difficult situations in their own authentic way.
Why This Matters More Than Ever
Customer expectations have fundamentally changed over the past few years. People are used to getting instant, personalised service from companies like Amazon and Uber. When they encounter old-school customer service – put on hold, transferred multiple times, given generic responses – it feels genuinely jarring.
At the same time, customers are more willing than ever to pay premium prices for businesses that treat them well. They'll forgive mistakes if they trust that you care about making things right.
This creates a massive opportunity for businesses that get customer service right. While your competitors are cutting costs and automating everything, you can differentiate yourself by actually caring about your customers as human beings.
It's not about being perfect. It's about being real.
Look, I'm not saying this is easy. Changing how your team approaches customer service requires genuine commitment from leadership, not just a new training program. But the businesses that make this shift consistently outperform their competitors in both customer retention and profitability.
Your customers aren't asking for miracles. They just want to feel heard, understood, and valued. Give them that, and everything else becomes much easier.
Other Resources Worth Reading: